Bach, Mozart, Beethoven and Schubert each left music that stops mid-thought: a fugue that breaks off soon after it spells its composer’s name, a Lacrimosa that ends after eight bars, a sonata with a blank page where the development should be. Claude Opus 5.5 read the manuscripts note by note and finished ten of them in the composers’ own language.
Black ink is theirs; blue ink is the machine’s. Every recording lets you hear the seam, the moment one hand stops and the other begins. After the ten completions come new pieces from the same collaboration: a fifth Season for Vivaldi, two movements of Mozart’s Requiem grown longer, an elegy and a fugue.
manuscripts completed
10
new and extended works
5
minutes of music
84
notes in blue ink
24,898
Bach stopsClaude Opus 5.5 continues
The end of Bach’s manuscript of The Art of Fugue, on the organ. Its third subject spells his name, BACH. Soon after all three subjects sound together for the first time, the page stops, and the blue notes begin.
The composer’s notes
Notes by Claude Opus 5.5
Where the manuscript stops
New music inside a finished movement
Each score is a picture of its recording: time runs left to right, pitch from low to high. Click anywhere on one to listen from there.
I.
Ten unfinished manuscripts
Chosen for how much survives and how much is missing: from a bar and a half of a chorale prelude to 239 bars of The Art of Fugue.
No. 1Johann Sebastian Bach
The Art of Fugue, Contrapunctus XIV
BWV 1080. Leipzig, late 1740s
Left239 bars. The manuscript breaks off just after the three subjects sound together for the first time. The third one spells his name: B flat, A, C, B natural.
Added56 bars. The fourth subject, the main theme of The Art of Fugue, joins the other three, as Gustav Nottebohm showed in 1881 that it could.
Bach stops9:55
0:00 / 12:23
No. 2Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Requiem, Lacrimosa and Amen
K. 626. Vienna, 1791
LeftEight bars of the Lacrimosa: the violins for two bars, then the choir and the bass. On a separate sketch leaf, sixteen bars of an Amen fugue.
AddedThe orchestra, the rest of the Lacrimosa, and a whole Amen fugue grown from his sketch. His sketched bars come back in black ink at 2:47.
Mozart stops0:46
0:00 / 5:25
No. 3Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Requiem, Amen fugue
K. 626, sketch leaf. Vienna, 1791
LeftSixteen bars on a sketch leaf now in Berlin: a fugue whose subject is the Requiem's opening theme turned upside down.
AddedThe rest of the fugue, for organ.
Mozart stops0:28
0:00 / 2:56
No. 4Franz Schubert
Symphony No. 8, “Unfinished”, Scherzo and Trio
D 759. Vienna, 1822
LeftNine bars in full score, then only a piano sketch: the whole Scherzo, and the first half of the Trio's melody with no harmony.
AddedThe orchestra from bar ten on, harmony for the Trio and its missing second half, and the return of the Scherzo.
The full score stops0:07
0:00 / 6:59
No. 5Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Movement in C minor for keyboard and violin
K. 396 (385f). Vienna, 1782
Left27 bars: a complete exposition. The violin waits until bar 23 to enter.
Added60 bars: the development and the recapitulation.
Mozart stops2:18
0:00 / 7:27
No. 6Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Allegro for clarinet and string quartet
K. 516c (Anh. 91)
Left93 bars in all five parts: the exposition and the first bars after it.
Added145 bars, to the end of the movement.
Mozart stops2:20
0:00 / 6:03
No. 7Johann Sebastian Bach
Fugue in C minor
BWV 906/2. Leipzig, about 1738
Left47 bars and a single chord: a deceptive cadence onto A flat, and then nothing.
Added50 bars, with the middle entries, stretto and pedal point Bach's text never reached.
Bach stops2:22
0:00 / 4:56
No. 8Ludwig van Beethoven
“Last musical thought”, String Quintet in C
WoO 62. Vienna, November 1826
Left24 bars of an Andante maestoso, known only from Diabelli's piano arrangement of 1838.
AddedThe string quintet he had in mind, and the rest of the movement.
Beethoven stops2:42
0:00 / 6:08
No. 9Johann Sebastian Bach
Orgelbüchlein, “O Traurigkeit, o Herzeleid”
BWV Anh. 200. Weimar, 1710s
LeftA title, a tempo (molt' adagio) and a bar and a half. The rest of the page is empty.
AddedThe whole chorale prelude, one statement of each of the hymn's five phrases.
Bach stops0:06
0:00 / 1:47
No. 10Franz Schubert
Piano Sonata in C-sharp minor
D 655. Vienna, April 1819
Left73 bars: the exposition, a repeat sign, and a blank page.
Added116 bars: the development and the recapitulation.
Schubert stops2:49
0:00 / 7:24
II.
New music
The same collaboration with no manuscript to finish. Each piece began as one sentence from Pedro, printed above it the way a score prints its tempo marking.
“Make a fifth Vivaldi season. Surprise me.”Pedro’s brief
La Quinta Stagione: Il Carnovale
A fifth Season, concerto in D major for violin, strings and harpsichord
In Vivaldi's Venice the year really had a fifth season: masks were legal for close to half of it, and the opera calendar he worked by had a Carnival season of its own. The concerto follows a new sonnet, as the Four Seasons do. An acrobat flies down from the Campanile, a tower of men is built and falls, a masked lover sings to a beloved who cannot answer, and the last night's dance is stopped by the midnight bell.
0:00 / 2:57
The sonnet
Vivaldi printed a sonnet with each Season and set its letters in the score, beside the music that depicts each line. This one is new. Choose a line to hear its music; while the concerto plays, the line it is depicting lights up.
“Keep its epicness, but add more, so the new parts are surprisingly unique and consistent with the rest.”Pedro’s brief
Rex tremendae, extended
Mozart, Requiem K. 626: 22 bars become 45
Every one of Mozart's 1,886 notes stays in place. Between “salvas gratis” and “salva me” come a hushed prayer on the chant tone of the Requiem's own Introit, a double fugue with the Requiem's opening theme in the trombone, a storm on “tremendae”, and a “Rex!” on a chord nobody expects. Then a bar of silence, and Mozart's own ending.
New music1:21 to 3:15
0:00 / 3:39
“Especially the motif of Quam olim Abrahae. That part is very powerful.”Pedro’s brief
Domine Jesu, extended
Mozart, Requiem K. 626: the Quam olim Abrahae fugue grows from 35 bars to 51
Just before Mozart's final cadence, the music swerves to E flat. The subject is sung upside down over a hushed chorale, then at half speed by three trombones, then the whole choir sings its opening on a diminished seventh and falls into the dominant. Mozart's last stretto returns, and his own cadence ends it. All 6,041 of his notes are where he put them.
New music4:06 to 4:48
0:00 / 5:18
“Very, very somber and sorrowful. Nostalgic of a future that never realized.”Pedro’s brief
Elegy for a Future That Never Came
For orchestra
A slow lament in F minor for woodwinds, horn, three trombones, timpani and strings, 40 bars long. The first orchestral piece of the project, with every note written out in the score.
0:00 / 3:41
“Compose and direct a fugue like Bach, grounded in music theory, that is beautiful.”Pedro’s brief
Fugue in C minor, a 3
Three voices, in the manner of Bach
The first piece of the project, in 21 bars: a subject, a tonal answer, an invertible countersubject, middle entries in E flat major and F minor, a dominant pedal, and a coda over a tonic pedal that ends in C major. Heard three ways.
0:00 / 1:44
III.
How it was made
The same eight steps for every piece. The boxed letters are rehearsal marks, the signs a conductor uses to say where to start.
A
Start from a sentence
Every piece began as a line from Pedro: a mood, a dare, a fragment worth finishing. The direction stayed Pedro's: what to attempt, what landed, what to push further.
“Nostalgic of a future that never realized.”
B
Research what was left unfinished
A research pass through catalogues, sketch studies and editions found melodies and movements the great composers began and abandoned. Ten were chosen for how much survives and how much is still missing.
Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert
C
Go back to the sources
Public-domain editions and manuscripts only: the Bach-Gesellschaft, the nineteenth-century complete editions of Mozart and Schubert, the Neue Mozart-Ausgabe, Mozart's sketch leaf, the Vienna delivery score of the Requiem, Schubert's autograph facsimile.
IMSLP and the Mozarteum's Digital Edition
D
Transcribe every note
Scanned pages were read staff by staff with a notehead scanner, then checked by eye against a second source where one exists; The Art of Fugue comes from a scholarly encoding of the Bach-Gesellschaft text. Where sources disagree, the doubt is written down instead of guessed away.
Mozart's Amen sketch: its barlines counted one by one on the facsimile, sixteen bars
E
Set rules the music cannot break
The composer's notes are sacred: a script compares every note before the seam with the source and fails on a single difference. The new music must pass a counterpoint check, with no parallel fifths or octaves between independent voices.
0 differences, in all ten completions and both extensions
F
Compose in their language
Each completion develops the composer's own motives in the forms and harmony of the time: Bach's three subjects meet the main theme of The Art of Fugue; the Quam olim subject is inverted and augmented, as a fugue of 1791 would do.
24,898 notes in blue ink on this page
G
Perform it
A rendering engine plays the scores with recorded instruments, all public domain, and a conductor: tempo, breaths, fermatas, balance. Phrases swell toward their peak, dissonances lean, leaps arrive a little late, leading tones lean sharp.
VSCO-2 and VCSL samples: orchestra, organ, upright piano, an Italian harpsichord
H
Listen back
Every recording is checked by machine before anyone hears it: the pitches of every beat against the score, clicks, loudness, the soloist's balance against the orchestra. Then by ear, and then the next sentence from Pedro.
Main pitch present in 87 to 97% of beats, 0 clicks
Fine
Credits
Black ink
Johann Sebastian Bach, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Ludwig van Beethoven and Franz Schubert.
Blue ink
Claude Opus 5.5, by Anthropic: the transcriptions, the completions, the new music, the orchestration and the performances.
Direction
Pedro Sánchez Gil: which pieces, what each one should feel like, and what to push further.
Sources
Public-domain scans from IMSLP and the Mozarteum’s Digital Mozart Edition; for The Art of Fugue, Craig Stuart Sapp’s Humdrum encoding of the Bach-Gesellschaft text.
Instruments
The VSCO-2 Community Edition and the Versilian Community Sample Library, both in the public domain. Every recording here is played by a program from those samples, not by musicians.